Why is Custom in Ear Better?

08 Apr.,2024

 

Audio earpiece commonly used in live music and television

JH Audio JH16 Pro IEMs, with a custom-molded hard acrylic shell Sensaphonics 2XS in-ears, with a custom-molded soft silicone shell Elize Ryd wearing in-ear monitors during a concert in 2018

In-ear monitors, or simply IEMs or in-ears, are devices used by musicians, audio engineers and audiophiles to listen to music or to hear a personal mix of vocals and stage instrumentation for live performance or recording studio mixing. They are also used by television presenters to receive vocal instructions, information and breaking news announcements from a producer that only the presenter hears. They are often custom-fitted to an individual's ears to provide comfort and a high level of noise reduction from ambient surroundings. Their origins as a tool in live music performance can be traced back to the mid-1980s.[1]

A stage monitor system is any system that provides a mix of audio sources to a performer on stage. Traditionally, loudspeakers were placed on the stage directed toward the performers. These loudspeakers can have disadvantages. First, floor wedges greatly increase the onstage volume, in some cases to potential hearing damage levels. Second, while floor wedges can be placed in front of a particular singer, guitarist, bassist, or drummer, the other musicians can often hear the other musicians' wedge mixes. In a sophisticated monitoring system, every band member can have their own monitor mix, which is their particular preference of vocals or instruments.

Since performers wear an IEM in each ear, they can also hear a stereo mix if a particular monitor system allows it. This can allow the additional definition of the audio by panning different elements (vocals, drums, etc.) to each ear. More recent advances allow the user to adjust the amount of ambient noise filtered by the IEM.

One additional consideration for mixing IEMs is that while eliminating floor wedges can improve the overall clarity of the mix for the performers and decrease the overall volume onstage, one important piece that is often lost is crowd noise and crowd comments, such as the audience calling for an encore. It is not uncommon for a microphone to be placed near each side of the stage, facing the audience, to provide a method to capture some of the crowd noise and audience comments back into the performers' IEM mixes. Larger live shows can have several microphones for this purpose spread across the front of the stage, which can also be sent to a multitrack recording device used in an outside broadcast production truck, or other destinations.[citation needed]

Transmitter and receiver

[

edit

]

A case of in ear monitor receivers

Most professional stage in-ear monitor systems use wireless technology to send the mix to the IEMs. This type of system consists of a stationary offstage transmitter and an onstage receiver (about the size of a deck of cards) that is worn by the performer. There is generally a transmitter for each monitor mix and there is always a receiver for each IEM. The transmitters usually output either one stereo mix or two mono mixes. When the transmitters are set up for two mono mixes, one transmitter can be used for two different mixes. Any number of receivers can receive a single mix.

The transmitters and receivers transfer audio wirelessly via a VHF or UHF radiofrequency. Generally speaking, UHF systems sound much better than VHF systems and are more expensive.[2] UHF systems usually are less susceptible to frequency interference which adds to their level of quality.[3]

Earpieces

[

edit

]

A pair of universal IEM earpieces (Etymotic ER-4S)

The in-ear monitors themselves are the last stage of the signal path in the system. They are placed in the external ear canal and seal against its sides; the effectiveness of this seal is a major part of the effectiveness of the IEM.

Universal IEMs typically include a variety of foam and silicone tips in each pack, with the goal that one pair may create a comfortable seal for the user's ears. If a universal IEM earpiece does not fit a specific person, they may need to order custom in-ear monitors. If there is not a good seal, ambient noise leakage is increased.

Custom molded IEMs are more comfortable to wear and better isolate ambient noise. Depending on the quality of the fit and length of the canal portion of the earpiece, a custom fit in-ear monitor will generally provide somewhere between 25 and 34 decibels of noise reduction. This means that loud onstage instruments, such as drum kit or large 8x12" guitar stacks, are less likely to cause hearing damage for onstage musicians wearing IEMs.

Custom in-ear monitors come in a variety of colors but are usually clear or a color that closely matches the skin color of the performer. Some manufacturers can also place custom artwork directly on the custom in-ear monitors. The IEM cable plugs into a 3.5  mm stereo jack on the receiver pack; typically clipped onto the belt, guitar strap, clothing of the performer, or placed in a pocket. Impressions for custom in-ear monitors are typically taken by an audiologist.  To achieve maximum isolation, the audiologist should use a high-viscosity impression material with a deep impression of the ear canal. The musician should also mimic their embouchure while the impression material is setting so that the fit is comfortable while performing. Custom in-ear monitors made of a softer silicone material can be inserted deeper in the ear canal and will provide more isolation from outside noise.[4][5]

Some performers desire a more natural sound from their IEMs with both the music mix and ambient sounds. Passive ambient IEMs have a small hole drilled into the earpiece to allow some natural ambient sound into the ear canal. This can potentially lead to increased sound exposure as it reduces the signal-to-noise ratio for the mix and causes the musician to increase the levels from the IEM. Active ambient IEMs use external microphones to reproduce the ambient sound in the mix that mimics the frequency response of the open ear and may sound more natural to the performer.[5][4]

Television studios use earpieces with a specialized type of intercom called an interruptible foldback (IFB), as a means of communication.

Driver technology

[

edit

]

Balanced armature

[

edit

]

Originally invented for hearing aids, balanced armature drivers are nowadays used extensively in modern in-ear monitors.[6][7][self-published source?][8] In-ear monitors can function with as little as one armature driver but some of the top models of in-ear monitors can carry as many as 18 balanced armature drivers for faster response, higher dynamic range, and more detailed sound. Notable examples include the Ultimate Ears Pro UE LIVE (6 balanced armature drivers and 2 dynamic drivers), JH Audio's Layla (12 balanced armature drivers), Noble Audio's K10U (10 balanced armature drivers), and 64 Audio's A18t (18 balanced armature drivers).

Dynamic

[

edit

]

The dynamic driver contains a diaphragm with a voice coil attached to it.  When an electric current passes through, the voice coil vibrates between the two permanent magnets resulting in the diaphragm moving and producing sound. Adherents of the dynamic driver cite better bass response.[7][self-published source?]

Safety

[

edit

]

Many performers choose to use IEMs as a way to reduce their overall exposure to loud sound and prevent hearing loss. However, education on the use of IEMs is a crucial factor for limiting exposure as performers have a tendency to set their IEMs to similar intensity levels that were previously used in their floor monitors. Musicians need to train themselves to listen at lower levels to take full advantage of the sound level reduction capability of IEMs.[4]

Some musicians with two IEMs may choose to take out one of them during a performance to hear more ambient sound. The increased risk of hearing damage in this scenario are twofold. Removing one IEM negates the improvement in signal-to-noise ratio from isolation and the binaural summation effect which causes an increase in perceived loudness from using two sound sources.[clarification needed] Therefore, the performer will likely turn up the IEM in the other ear to improve the signal-to-noise ratio. Also, the ear without an IEM is potentially exposed to loud ambient sound.[4][5]

Many IEMS use peak limiters or compressors to limit potential damage from sudden loud sounds. However, this does not prevent the performer from turning up the IEM to unsafe levels.[5]

See also

[

edit

]

References

[

edit

]

It goes without saying that everyone's tastes are different. With that in mind I want to share the general rules of thumb when it comes to choosing between custom fit and universal fit in-ear monitors. Our in-ear monitors, or IEMs/earphones, are top of the line tools purpose built to provide our customers with the best quality sound imaginable. For most people, there is an extra edge to be gained when considering the custom-fit options.

What's the difference?

The entire experience is subtly changed when moving from a universal fit to a custom fit in-ear monitor. Instead of a bead of foam or silicone being the single point of seal against your ear canal, that pressure is distributed across a much broader area in the form of the custom fit shell. The seal is more thorough, and some say more comfortable given the extra surface area involved. 

The sound profile even changes ever so slightly. The bass is a touch fuller and there is the barest hint more headroom. These subtle changes are important in the professional arena where detail, clarity and accuracy are king. There is a slight learning curve when using custom fit in-ear monitors, putting them in can be a big strange. Once you've sorted it out, however, it will fit more securely. 

The universal shells provide a degree of modularity not available with custom fit shells, and are quite popular with audiophiles. If you need to tailor your sound exactly the way you want it and intend to swap tips and cables around frequently, than the universal shell is the way to go.

Extremely ergonomic and organic in its design, our universal shell is designed to fit comfortably in anyone's ear. If this is a tool meant to be shared (by a rotating staff of musicians or speakers at a school or church, for example) then universal shells are the better choice. 

When is Custom Fit the Right Choice?

  • If you're an energetic performer on stage you need the secure fit of a custom shell. 
  • If you want to express yourself with your design, get a custom shell.
  • If the best possible isolation is imperative, a custom in-ear monitor would provide.

When is Universal Fit the Right Choice

  • If the IEMs will be shared among multiple users, or if kept as a backup for a group's custom fit models, the universal models will sort you out. 
  • If you want to take advantage of different tips, a universal shell is a must. 
  • If you can't wait the 3 to 5 weeks it takes us to hand craft a custom built in-ear monitor for you, the universal models usually ship within 24 hours when in stock. Instant gratification!

Either Way

Either way you'll be getting yourself the best sounding piece of personal audio equipment available on the market. If you want to give yourself an edge in your performances or if you want to take your critical listening to a whole new universe, a custom or universal Empire Ears in-ear monitor will blow your mind. 

Why is Custom in Ear Better?

When Custom In Ear Monitors Are The Right Choice